This study immunolocalized perlecan, Type I and II collagen and aggrecan in human foetal joint rudiment cartilages of the hip, knee and elbow. Blood vessels in the stromal tissues, associated with the cartilage rudiments were also prominently stained with perlecan, entrapped red blood cells aided in their identification. Perlecan was a prominent extracellular matrix proteoglycan in the rudiment cartilages. Stem cell niches close to the margins of the cartilage rudiments were prominently identified in the hip, knee and elbow and were distinguishable from the aforementioned blood vessels which were located in the rudiment associated stromal tissues. Type I collagen was also immunolocalized to the outer margins of the rudiment cartilages where perlecan positive niches were also present whereas the remainder of the rudiment contained type II collagen. Stem cell niches similar to those observed in the present study have previously been identified in the human foetal elbow.
Cartilage rudiment; Human foetal joint development; Stem cell niche
Stem cell niches similar to those observed in the present study have previously been identified in the human foetal elbow . The aim of the present study was to determine if similar structures were also evident in hip and knee joint rudiments.
The stem cell is a specialized cell type that undergoes self-renewal to maintain a self-sustaining undifferentiated cell population within the stem cell niche .The specialized microenvironment of the stem cell niche provides chemical and physical feedback cues which maintain the stem cells in a slowly recycling state of self renewal . The stem cell niche acts as a reserve of cells for the replenishment of damaged or dead cells with ageing or in disease or after traumatic damage to the tissue maintaining viable cell numbers and tissue homeostasis.
Perlecan (HSPG2) is a modular proteoglycan interactive with diverse Extracellular Matrix (ECM) and cellular components [4-6]. Perlecan is a major HS substituted proteoglycan component of basement membranes and vascular tissues  and is also present in a vascular tissues such as articular cartilage, intervertebral disc, meniscus and tendon where it is present as a hybrid HS-CS proteoglycan [8-11]. Interactions between perlecan and structural and cell adhesive glycoproteins such as laminin, fibronectin, WARP (von Willebrand A domain-Related Protein), PRELP (Proline/Arginine-Rich End Leucine-Rich repeat protein), type IV collagen, type VI collagen, fibrillin-1, Latent Transforming growth factor Β1 Binding Protein-2 (LTBP2), α2β1 and α5β1 integrins stabilize the ECM [12-14]. The HS chains of perlecan domain-1 bind Fibroblast Growth Factors (FGF), Vascular Endothelial Cell Growth Factor (VEGF), Platelet Derived Growth Factor (PDGF), BMP family members, Wnt (wingless-type MMTV [Mouse Mammary Tumor Virus]) integration site related proteins, hedgehog proteins regulating cellular adhesion, proliferation, differentiation, ECM synthesis, chondrogenesis and tissue morphogenesis during skeletal development [8,14-17].
Perlecan is a component of a number of stem cell niches located in the allantois, intestine, bone marrow, limbal epithelium, nervous system and elbow perichondrium [1,18-23]. Perlecan has a role in the isolation of the stem cells from ECM components outside the niche which could result in activation, migration and development of differentiated stem cell lineages . FGF-2 is a major ligand for perlecan with roles in the long term viability of the niche stem cells [22,23]. Perlecan displays anti-adhesive properties to stem cells in bone marrow contributing to their isolation from extrinsic influences . ECM components extrinsic to the niche are known to exert directive cues on cellular proliferation, adhesion and differentiation of stem cells . Perlecan colocalises with type VI collagen pericellularly in chondrocytes and intervertebral disc cells [25,26]. Atomic Force Microscopy has demonstrated that perlecan provides compliancy to the type VI collagen pericellular matrix [27,28] and modulates tensile stresses otherwise transmitted to cells within tensional and weight bearing connective tissues through type VI collagen . Perlecan also provides an adhesive interface between the chondrocyte and its surrounding ECM . The cartilage rudiments act as a transient developmental scaffold transformed by chondroprogenitor cell populations during endochondral ossification resulting in elongation of the long bones and extension of the axial skeleton .
Materials and Methods
Supplier details are as indicated in earlier studies, information on the use of the monoclonal antibodies to perlecan domain-1 (mAb A76), type I and II collagen, and aggrecan are also supplied in these publications [8-10]. Human foetal tissues (knees, elbow , hip) from one 10 week, three 12 week and four 14 week gestational age human fetuses were obtained with informed consent and all procedures were approved by our institutional ethics review committee.
The stem cell niche and ECM components in macroscopic views of foetal hips
Cartilage canals were prominent features of the cartilaginous hip rudiment at 14 weeks gestational age (Figure 1). Perlecan and aggrecan were widely distributed throughout the rudiment (Figures 1a &1c). Type II collagen was also a prominent component of the hip rudiment in all but a surface region where type I collagen immunolocalizes (data not shown). This area was evident as a blue region in the type II immunolocalizations (Figures 1b & 1e). Small punctate regions of high perlecan localization delineated the stem cell niches in the surface regions of the rudiment (Figure 1d) within a region devoid of type II collagen (Figure 1e) but rich in aggrecan (Figure 1f).
Higher power views of hip stem cell niches
Higher magnification views of the hip rudiment perlecan immunolocalizations clearly depicted the small stem cell niches (Figures 2a-2c). Cartilage canals were larger and also contained perlecan in their outer walls (Figure 2b).
Stem cell niches in foetal knee rudiment cartilages
Examination of knee rudiment cartilages also demonstrated a prominent extracellular localization of perlecan throughout the femoral and tibial rudiments (Figure 3a). Small networks of cells within the surface regions of the rudiments were also prominently delineated by the perlecan immunolocalisations. We consider these are the stem cell niches and were clearly seen at higher magnification (Figures 3b & 3c) and clearly distinguishable from blood vessels which also contain perlecan immunolocalised in the vessel wall (Figures 3d & 3e). Red blood cells were observed within some blood vessels aiding in their identification. A venule (Figure 3d) and arteriole (Figure 3e) are shown. Blood vessels were considerably larger than the stem cell stained structures (Figure 3b) which occurred in the rudiment margins whereas blood vessels were present only in the stromal tissue associated with the rudiments and did not occur in the rudiments (Figures 3d & 3e).
Stem cell niches have characteristic morphologies and distributions in the surface region of the cartilage rudiments of joints
Closer examination of the surface regions of a number of knee joints consistently identified these niche localisations of perlecan in the surface regions of the cartilaginous rudiments (Figures 41-4d) in a region rich in type I collagen (Figure 4e) whereas the rudiment proper contained type II collagen (Figure 4f). Aggrecan was immunolocalized diffusely throughout this outer marginal rudiment tissue zone as well as the rudiment proper (Figure 4g). While blood vessels were also prominently visualized in the stromal tissues bordering the rudiments these had a clearly differing morphology to the stem cell niche immunolocalizations of perlecan (Figure 4h). Examination of an unstained cartilage specimen by Nomarski differential interference contrast microscopy showed that cellular morphologies and arrangement of matrix components were clearly different in all of the 3 zones, stroma (zone 1), rudiment margin (zone 2) and rudiment (zone 3) (Figures 4i-4k). The cell density in zone 1 was lower than the other two zones (Figure 4i) whereas in the marginal tissue of the rudiment prominent longitudinal fibrillar material was present running parallel to the rudiment surface (Figure 4j). The cells in this region had an elongated morphology (Figure 4k), type I collagen was immunolocalized to this tissue region (Figure 4e). The cells within the rudiment proper (zone 3) had a rounded morphology typical of chondrocytes and were considerably larger than the cells in the stromal tissue or rudiment margins. The cells in zone 3 were contained within lacunae similar to those seen in hyaline cartilaginous tissues.
Type I collagen immunolocalizes to the surface regions of newborn hip joints
Unfortunately we were unable to source newborn human tissue for comparison with the foetal tissue however immunolocalization of type I collagen in newborn lamb hip tissue also demonstrated it had a prominent localization in the surface region of the hip (Figure 5a) and around the cartilage canals within it. The hip tissue is cartilaginous at this stage of development. In contrast to the type I collagen immunolocalizations, type II collagen and aggrecan were immunolocalized throughout the hip rudiment (Figures 5b & 5c). Perlecan was also immunolocalized throughout the hip specimens (Figure 5d). The prominent stem cell niche arrangements so evident in the human foetal joint rudiments examined in this study were not evident in the newborn hip specimens which apparently indicates these are developmental features of human foetal joints. Immunolocalization of perlecan in a 10 week old human foetal hip rudiment showed perlecan was a prominent ECM proteoglycan, small arrangements similar to those observed in the other foetal cartilages were again present in the surface regions of the rudiments however the humeral head had not completely separated from the adjacent acetabulum at this stage of joint development (Figure 5e). Such perlecan positive arrangements were also observed in a 12 week old human foetal elbow rudiment (Figure 5f) in the surface regions of the cartilage rudiments (Figures 5g & 5h).
The present study demonstrated roles for perlecan in foetal human joint development not only as an ECM component in the cartilaginous rudiments but also as a stem cell niche component with potential roles in the regulation of stem cell differentiation. This is in keeping with perlecans known roles in chondrogenesis  and the regulation of cellular adhesion and proliferation in skeletal development [5,15,16,30]. The complexity of the dynamic native stem cell niche microenvironment is a function of the surface biochemistry, topography (type, size, organization, and geometry of nanostructures), and their mechanical properties determining whether the stem cell remains in a quiescent non-differentiated state or otherwise. Signalling pathways involving Notch, Wingless-type (Wnt), Sonic hedgehog (Shh), and Smad proteins are important determinants of self-renewal and differentiation of stem cells. Type I collagen is a component of many stem cell niches [31,32] and may provide an interactive mechanical and biochemical niche environment conducive to stem cell differentiation, adhesion and migration [33-38]. MSCs sense a 3D environment containing type I collagen through discoid in domain receptor-1 . The localization of type I collagen around the stem cell niches identified in the present study may therefore be important for stem cell differentiation and the morphogenesis of rudiment cartilage to bone . Type I collagen occurs in tissues to counter tensional forces, the tensional properties of growth surfaces have been shown to be an important modulator of stem cell behavior. Perlecan colocalises with collagen networks in the pericellular matrix of cells providing compliancy properties to tissues thus the localization of perlecan in the stem cell niche may counter the tensile properties conveyed by the type I collagen outside the niche. Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) of single hip chondrocytesin a mouse model of Schwartz Jampel syndrome demonstrated a significant effect on cell and tissue stiffness implicating outside-in mechanical signalling from the pericellular matrix as a dynamic stimulant to cellular development . A similar scenario may also apply to the regulation of stem cells in the perlecan niches observed in the present study. While we refer to these as stem cell niches throughout this manuscript these should more correctly be considered “putative” stem cell niches based on the data we have presented in the present study. Unfortunately we were not able to undertake immunolocalizations with other antibodies to confirm the identity of these perlecan positive structures and this is a weakness of our study. However we considered the observations we made were nevertheless important enough to expound such an interpretation and in our opinion terming these as niches fitted a number of criteria proposed in other studies as to what constitutes a niche. Further studies should aim to rectify this deficiency.
The Wnt family of growth factors are ancient metazoan proteins which are conserved throughout vertebrate and invertebrate evolution. Wnt proteins (the name Wnt is a fusion of the name for the Drosophila segment polarity gene ‘wingless’ and its vertebrate homolog, ‘integrated or int-1’) regulate stem cell fate, migration, proliferation and self-renewal [40-44]. Extracellular Wnt protein induces a number of intracellular signal transduction pathways of importance in stem cell differentiation, tissue development and repair [40,41,43-45]. Perlecan regulates bi-directional Wnt signaling in Drosophila [40,46-49] and growth factor signaling in C.elegans  and also stabilizes the matrix surrounding the stem cell niche. Recent studies in the human foetal elbow showed that perlecan localized with type I collagen surrounding the stem cell niches . Type I collagen normally conveys tensile forces in tissues, AFM studies have shown that perlecan provided compliancy to the type VI collagen pericellular matrix surrounding chondrocytes where these components were co-localized as in IVD cells [25,27,28]. Thus the perlecan, which delineates the stem cell niches observed in the present study, may modulate the propagation of tensile forces to the niche stem cells from their external micro-environment. Knockdown of perlecan lowers in-situ cell and matrix stiffness in developing cartilage . The stem cell microenvironment is influenced by matrix stiffness, and mechanical forces experienced from fluid shear, compression and tension, and these regulate the proliferation and differentiation of stem cells [51-54]. MSCs sense biomechanical forces through primary cilia which are colocalised with calcium ion channels resulting in responsive changes in mechanosensitive ion channel associated proteins such as transient receptor potential melastatin 7, a mechanosensitive plasma membrane calcium channel protein, and changes in their cytoskeleton . An influx of Ca2+ ions into MSCs has attendant effects on the formation of intracellular signaling molecules such as inositol triphosphate, changes in the actin/actomyosin cytoskeleton and the activation of associated signaling pathways. The associated change in cell shape and co-ordination of focal adhesions acts as a primer for MSC migration. MSCs are also capable of secreting active heparanase-1 which degrades the HS side chains of perlecan . Heparanase released from MSCs also activates Integrin beta1/HIF-2alpha/Flk-1 signaling and stem cell migration [55,56]. Many stem cell populations utilize the SDF-1/CXCR4 axis to effect migration [57-61]. The release of progenitor cell populations from their niches by heparanase-1 is consistent with emerging roles for heparanase-1 and 2 in the promotion of wound repair [62,63]. Live cell imaging of stem cell niches where the niche is de-stressed results in a change in the stem cell quiescent state to a migratory phenotype which can home to sites of tissue damage [64,65]. This is consistent with roles proposed for biomechanical forces and ECM directive cues in the regulation of stem cell phenotype in-vivo and the promotion of wound healing [3,66-69].
The stem cell arrangements visualized in the present study were present in the rudiment margins and were clearly distinguishable from blood vessels in the stromal tissues. Like other cartilages, the rudiments contain anti-angiogenic proteins refractory to the penetration of blood vessels [14,70]. An earlier confocal study of the human foetal elbow demonstrated perlecan positive niches in the outer regions of the perichondrium along the shaft of the long bones . Activated stem cells displaying the CS sulphation motifs 4C3, 3B3(-) and 7D4 were closely associated with these perlecan positive niches . Chondroprogenitor stem cells have also been identified in the surface regions of the presumptive articular cartilage of the knee joint following joint cavitation [71,72].
With an increased awareness of the role of extrinsic forces on stem cell regulation in situ , regenerative approaches are now being developed using bio-scaffolds with defined tunable tensional properties to modulate stem cell differentiation in vitro . Decellularised tissues with their ECM, biochemical and structural cues intact in the stem cell niche are also being evaluated for their ability to modulate stem cell behaviour in culture and modify stem cell proliferation and differentiation . The stiffness of biomaterials is an important determinant which drives stem cell proliferation and differentiation . Evaluation of matrices synthesized by human fibroblasts has shown an increase in stem cell proliferation and differentiation, down-regulation of adipogenesis and osteogenesis but promotion of chondrogenesis . In the human foetal elbow the perichondrial stem cell niche is contained in a matrix layed down by fibroblastic cells in the outer regions of the perichondrium. These regions of the perichondrium are rich in type I collagen  and are similar to the areas of type I collagen deposition between the rudiment and associated stromal tissues observed in the present study and which also contain stem cell niches.
Matricryptins and matrikines have received considerable attention as prospective agents for tissue repair through their ability to modify stem cell behavior stimulating proliferation and differentiation , some matrikines stimulate stem cell migration. Chondroitin Sulphate (CS) is another Glycosaminoglycan (GAG) which is considered indispensable for stem cell pluripotency and stem cell differentiation , We are now in an exciting era in regenerative medicine and may be optimistic that armed with greater knowledge on how stem cells are regulated in their niches we may someday be able to manipulate these to improve their replicative, differentiative and migratory properties in situ to obtain the critical numbers of stem cells of specific cell lineages required at defect sites for regenerative applications. It is to be expected that a greater understanding of how stem cells target damaged tissues will also greatly improve the utility of stem cells as therapeutic agents.
This study was supported by NHMRC Project Grant 1004032.
Susan M Smith undertook the immunolocalizations presented in this study, reviewed the final version of the manuscript and assisted in writing the methods section. James Melrose obtained funding, conceptualized the study, collected and interpreted data, prepared figures and wrote the manuscript.
Figure 1: Immunolcalization of perlecan (a,d), type II collagen (b,e) and aggrecan (c,f) in a 14 week old gestational age human foetal hip joint. Macrosopic views. Chromogen NovaRED, Scale bar 100 µm.
Figure 2: Higher power magnifications of the perlecan immunolocalizations depicted in figure 2a using perlecan domain-1 mAb A76. The boxed area in (b) is decocted in the inset (c). Small stem cell niches are prominent in the marginal tissue of the hip cartilage rudiments. Three cartilage canals are also evident deeper in the specimen. Perlecan is also an extracellular component of the cartilage rudiment. Scale bars 100 µm.
Figure 3: Immunolocalization of perlecan in a 12 week old gestational age human foetal human knee. Macroscopic view (a) and higher power magnification of areas of interest (boxed areas in (a). Stem cell niches are prominently immunolocalized (b, c). Immunolocalization of perlecan delineating a venule (d) and arteriole (e) in the stromal tissue surrounding the cartilage rudiment. Red blood vessels are visible within these vessels aiding in their identification as blood vessels. Scale bar 100 µm.
Figure 4: Immunocalization of stem cell niches using mAb A76 to perlecan domain-1 in the outer margins of a tibial cartilaginous rudiment (12 week gestational age) (a-d) and type I collagen (e) type II collagen (f) and aggrecan (Acan) (g) in the cartilaginous rudiment (zone 3) and rudiment marginal tissue (zone 2). Immunolocalization of two prominent blood vessels in the stromal tissue (zone 1) adjacent to the rudiment (zones 2,3). Perlecan is also an extracellular matrix component in zone 3 (h). Unstained black and white Nomarski phase contrast DIC images of representative areas of zone 1-3 clearly identifying differences in cellular morphology and matrix organization in these areas (4i-4k).
Figure 5: Macroscopic immunolocalization of type I collagen (a), type II collagen (b) aggrecan (c) and perlecan (d) in a newborn ovine hip joint and 10 week gestational age human foetal hip joint which has only partially separated from the acetabulum (e) and a 12 week old human foetal elbow (f). Cartilage canals are prominent in (a-d). Small stem cell niches are evident in the marginal rudiment tissues of (e and f). NovaRED Chromogen, Scale bars 100 µm.