Journal of Gerontology & Geriatric Medicine Category: Medical Type: Review Article
Mechanisms of Longevity Phenomenon in Azerbaijan
- Kuznetsova SM1*, Kamilova NM2, Kuznetsov VV1
- 1 Department Of Neurology, DF Chebotarev Institute Of Gerontology, Kiev, Ukraine
- 2 National Academy Of Sciences Of Azerbaijan, Baku, Azerbaijan
*Corresponding Author:Kuznetsova SM
Department Of Neurology, DF Chebotarev Institute Of Gerontology, Kiev, Ukraine
Received Date: Nov 05, 2016 Accepted Date: Dec 05, 2016 Published Date: Dec 09, 2016
The goal of the study was to identify and explore the social-ethnic and medical-biological factors underlying the formation of the ‘longevity phenomenon’ in the Azerbaijan region. The study involved 260 long-lived (90-112 years of age) and 3,700 younger-aged subjects (45-89 years) from the Azerbaijan population. The discussed findings highlight the role and interaction of specific social-environmental factors (gerontocratic character of traditional ethnic culture, type of nutrition and psychological personality structure) and molecular-biological mechanisms (anthropometric constitutional types, peculiarities of the bioelectrical brain activity and chromosome polymorphism by heterochromatin) in the Azerbaijanian ‘longevity phenomenon’.
Long-living people are the representatives of maximal species-specific lifespan. Search for the mechanisms and factors determining longevity has been carried out at the various levels from population to molecular-cellular . The long-lived are registered in various regions of the globe. Still, the geography of longevity shows that these regions are distributed irregularly. High concentration of the long-lived is observed in the Caucasus . Here there are national-ethnic groups with high longevity index. The highest longevity level is registered in Abkhazia and Azerbaijan . Among the aboriginal population of these regions there has naturally-historically emerged and been fixed the high concentration of the long-lived, called the phenomenon of group longevity .
Assessment of the effects of the social-ethnic and medical-biological factors on the formation of the ‘longevity phenomenon’ in Azerbaijan.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Since 2015 year the research on ‘the longevity phenomenon’ in Azerbaijan has been renewed by the investigators of Azerbaijan Medical Institute and A.I. Karaev Institute of Physiology who invited their colleagues from the Kiev Institute of Gerontology to join them . The survey program includes study of ecology, national-ethnic characteristics of lifestyle , nutrition  and anthropology (race-morphologic signs)  etc., analyzed with the use of modern methods have been the nervous, cardiovascular, endocrine systems, the physical-chemical and biochemical composition of the blood [8,9]. A special interest has been paid to study the role of heredity in the “longevity phenomenon”, family genealogy and polymorphism of separate genes .
- Clinical (patient’s complaints, neurologist’s and physician’s examination)
- Questionnaire to verify age, age-related subjective signs of aging 
- Biological age assessment [11,12]
- Anthropometric data [3,7]
- Brain bioelectrical activity based on electroencephalographic data [13,14]
- Duplex ultrasound examination of neck vessels and brain 
- Family history and tracing family longevity and family diseases such like cerebral-vascular pathology, age of the deceased and causes of their death 
- Cytogenetic investigations (variants of chromosome polymorphism as regards C-heterochromatin, absolute and relative sizes of C-band lengths on the chromosomes 1, 9, 16 and Y, heteromorphism of C-blocks on the homologues of the chromosomes 1, 9, 16 and Y [10,14,16,17]
- Factual nutrition using questionnaire weighing and questionnaire sheet methods .
- Ethnic-psychological testing (Eysenck test for extra and intraversion, Massachusetts personality questionnaire, Luscher test) [5,18].
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The socio-psychological factors of ‘longevity “phenomenon’
Psychological personality structure
For the assessment of the type of personality, emotionality and will power, various psycho-diagnostic techniques were used, such as locus control scales, lusher test and MMSE . According to the authors’ findings, the long-lived are characterized by internality, i.e., presence of internal control, as they feel themselves the masters of their life/fate. They predominately consider: “while fulfilling the will of the God, I should act in this way, meaning that the outcome of the event depends on me”. The Azerbaijani oldest people have highly preserved intellect and feeling of humor .
In Azerbaijan, the long-lived have an ambivalent attitude to old age. That is, ritual parallels emotional. They shade the fact of aging and oust worry caused by aging. They exhibit very low level of anxiety, high social adaptability and wide emotional associations . In 80% of the interviewed cases the long-lived did not consider their age very high. They possess psychological protection against recognition of the fact of aging and inevitable death which is determined by the peculiarities of their character such as low anxiety level, communicativeness and pliability of psychic reactions [21,22]. It is worth to recall the utterance of Gufeland in 1853: “among the influences shortening lifespan predominant are the fear, sadness, depression, envy and hatred”. The known proverb says: ‘good will is the reward and evil is the punishment’ for oneself. It is known that time perception changes with aging: in as much as man is getting older his subjective perception of the quickened time passage increases . The long-living Azerbaijani, compared even with the long-living Ukrainians and Byelorussians, have less marked feeling of ‘quickened time passage’ and they stand nearer to the age group of 40-50 year old .
The centenarians are good-wishers and never refer to long-passed events as most aging people do. Among severely ill there are no hypochondriacs even among the sick persons . The majority long-lived are extraverts and communicative, sanguine in temperament, disposed to pleasure and easily adaptive to their social environment . Speaking about their volitional sphere, the long-lived have modest pretensions. Through their whole life course practically all of them give preferences to calmness and peaceful solution of conflicts. The volitional process has no high tension and is aimed mainly at the preservation of their personal and social status-quo .
Brain functional state
The tempo of age-related cerebral circulation changes and myocardial contractile capacity in the long-living Azerbaijani is also slowed compared to other national-regional groups [9,31]. The results of complex clinical-instrumental investigation of individuals over 90 years residing in the Kazakh and Islamabad areas of Azerbaijan show that within morbidity structure of hypertensive disease makes 12%, IHD 35%, residual stroke phenomena 2% and extra pyramidal deficiency 9%. Health level of the long-lived of Ukraine is significantly lower and complex pathology is more pronounced. 65% of the examined Ukrainian long-lived had hypertensive disease, 80% IHD and 12% Parkinson’s disease .
According to the results of clinical-instrumental examination of the long-lived, carried out in 2015 year in the Lenkaran district of Azerbaijan, the arterial hypertension was diagnosed in 20% and Ischemic Heart Disease (IHD) in 40%. Thus there are no differences as to hypertension and IHD prevalence in the long-lived in various regions of Azerbaijan .
Noteworthy is the high maintenance of cerebral circulation in the long-living of Azerbaijan. Thus, according to the data of doppler ultrasound examination of the head and neck vessels of the long-lived, carried out in the 2015 year, we registered initial signs of cerebral atherosclerosis proved by normal sizes of the Intima-Media Complex (IMC) of common carotid artery (0.8-1.0 mm) in 50% and only slightly increased IMC in 50% (1.1-1.2 mm) in the examined long-lived residing in the Lenkaran district. The frequency of ICA stenosis was more than 50-75% being diagnosed in 14% of the examined long-lived and in 21.4% among populational elderly subjects (control).
Noteworthy is the high maintenance of cerebral blood circulation in the long-living of Azerbaijan. Thus, according to above-mentioned doppler ultrasound examination of head and neck vessels of in the long-lived, we registered only initial signs of cerebral atherosclerosis. We performed analysis of the incidence and structure of atherosclerotic plaques in the Internal Carotid Artery (ICA) in the long-living individuals and control subjects. The absence of atherosclerotic plaques in the right ICA was observed in 66% of the long-lived and in 50% in the left ICA. Their absence in the control subjects was respectively 71.4% and 85.7% (Figure 2).
The most ‘aggressive’ hypoechogenic atherosclerotic plagues were registered in the left Internal Carotid Artery (ICA) in 4.2% of long-lived and in the right ICA in 7.1% of control subjects. The frequency of hypoechogenic (stable) atherosclerotic plagues was registered in the right ICA in 8.3% and in the left ICA in 4.2% of long-lived. This type of plagues was not found in the control subjects. It is noteworthy that both long-lived and control individuals showed predominant occurrence of the heterogenic (mixed) atherosclerotic plagues: in 25% in the right ICA and in 41.7% in the left ICA; and respectively in 21.4% and in 14.3% in the control (Figure 2).
The indices of common carotid intima media and the frequency and structure of the atherosclerotic plaques suggest that structural changes of extra cranial vessels in the carotid basin of the long-lived correspond to these indices in the elderly subjects (control).
In the long-lived the Linear Systolic Blood Flow Velocity (LSBFV) is somewhat decreased compared with elderly subjects (control). In the former the blood flow velocity in the right ICA makes 66.6±7.1 cm/s (p< 0.05) and in the left 69.9±3.7 cm/s (p<0.05), whereas in the control group these indices are respectively 84.1±3.2 and 81.8±2.5 cm/s; in the medialmedullary artery 67.9±7.9 from the right and 76.7±4.2 cm/s (p<0.05) from the left and in the control subjects respectively 74.2±4.8 and 87.6±33 cm/s.
On evidence derived from the peripheral Resistance Indicators (RI), no angiospasm was detectable in the vessels of the carotid and vertebra-basilar basins in the long-lived. In the long-lived, Ri in the right Internal Carotid Artery (ICA) is 0.71±0.01, in the left ICA - 0.66±0.02, and in the elderly subjects respectively 0.65±.07 and 0.64±0.08; in the from the right 0.6±0.02 and from the left 0.61±0.01 and in the medial medullary artery 0.58±0.09 and 0.57±0.07 in the control, respectively.
Noteworthy is the functional maintenance of cerebral hemodynamic in the vertebra-basilar basin. Thus in the long-lived the LSBFV in the occipital artery makes 63.79±6.1 cm/s (p<0.05) compared to 50.5±5.8 cm/s in the control. In the long-lived the size of the vertebral artery is larger (right 2.95 mm and left 2.88 mm) compared to the elderly subjects (right 2.68 mm and left 2.84 mm) that corresponds to active blood flow in the vertebral-basilar system .
Thus, the long-lived have an insignificant decrease of cerebral hemodynamic in the carotid basin vessels against the background of activated hemodynamic in the Vertebra-Basilar Basin (VBB) vessels. The VBB basin supplies blood to the stem reticular-diencephalon structures of the brain that, probably, determines the wide range of central regulation of the cardio-vascular system in the long-lived.
The pattern of age changes in the cardiovascular and nervous systems and morbidity structure in various national-ethnic groups of (Abkhazians, Azerbaijani, Georgians and Ukrainians) gave grounds not only to make an assumption about slowed mode of aging in the regions with high longevity level but also to formulate a hypothesis about the syndromes of aging [14,21]. These syndromes or portraits of aging are also characteristic of the long-lived. Thus a relatively high functional level of the cardiovascular system and a low prevalence of this system pathology (IHD and arterial hypertension) are maintained.
|Content||Recommended values by Yu. Grigorov |
A wide prevalence of cardiovascular diseases is nowadays ascribed to the deficit of the polyunsaturated acids and excessive intake of cholesterol in the food . In addition, the observable vitamin E deficit and its ratio with food content of polyunsaturated fatty acids also play role: the greater its ratio, the higher so called antioxidant protection of the food.
Noteworthy is the high intake of the garlic and onions by the long-lived. In the Egyptian papyrus of 1550 year devoted to medicine there are 22 recipes mentioning garlic. The garlic reduces the level of cholesterol and total lipids in the blood. It contains components with distinctly expressed antitumor activities, which are as active as aspirin . Tea is part of the traditional nutrition of the long-lived. Regular use of freshly-brewed tea promotes vitamin C accumulation. Tea causes expansion of skin pores and enhances sweating that reduces skin temperature. It is clear that tea in hot climate helps organism’s adaptation.
Studies carried out in the long-lived of the three regions (Azerbaijan, Abkhasia and Ukraine) allowed identify both, general and ethnic variants of chromosomal polymorphism by the heterochromatin. The general variant of chromosomal polymorphism is characterized by the presence in the long-living males of three regions of the long Y-chromosome and a large block of C-heterochromatin on the Y-chromosome and chromosome 1. The long Y-chromosome was also found in the relatives of the long-lived. In the long-living females of Azerbaijan, Abkhasia and Ukraine the variants of chromosomal polymorphism are characterized by the presence of the large block of C-heterochromatin on the chromosome 9 and a high frequency of the associations of the acrocentric chromosomes evidencing for the high activity of ribosomal RNA synthesis [16,17,35].
Thus certain cytogenetic markers by heterochromatin are characteristic for the long-lived. Data about the role of heterochromatin in the evolution, association of chromosomal polymorphism variants with essential phenotypic characteristics (reproduction, viability) and pathological processes (malignancies), regulating the impact of heterochromatin sizes on the gene recombination and, lastly, the difference of eco-resistance of the homo- and heterozygote’s by C-chromatin allow us believe that variants of chromosomal polymorphism in the long-lived are the manifestation of certain molecular-genetic mechanisms determining longevity [16,23,35].
Complex analysis of the role of social-environmental and genetic processes in the formation of the longevity phenomenon in Azerbaijan has allowed us formulate the proposition that this phenomenon is the result of complex harmonic interaction of the environmental, national-ethnic-psychological factors and the peculiarities of genetic organization. We believe that further investigation of the ‘longevity phenomenon’ in Azerbaijan with the use of modern informative clinical-instrumental, molecular-genetic and biochemical methods will allow decode complex mechanisms of longevity formation and maybe these data will be used successfully for increasing of the populational and human individual lifespan.
- International Federation on Ageing (2015) IV Turyak International Congress on “Longevity”, International Federation on Ageing, Ontario, Canada
- Kozlov VI (1982) Study of the longevity problems. In: Longevity phenomenon. Moscow: Nauka 5-12.
- Kozlov VI (1989) [Longevity in Azerbaijan: a collection of papers] Dolgozhitel'stvo v Azerbaidzhane: sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Nauka, Mascow, USSR. Pg no: 189.
- Bezrukov VV, Kuznetsova CM, Kamilova NM, Aliev R (2015) The mechanisms of the phenomenon of longevity in Azerbaijan. Journal Neurology. BN Mankowski 3.
- Starovoitova GV (1982) The ethnic-psychological aspects of longevity phenomenon. In: Longevity phenomenon, Moscow, Russia.
- Kecskes Z (2003) Large fetomaternal hemorrhage: clinical presentation and outcome. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 13:128-132.
- Bacewicz VA, Pavlovsky OM, Chizhikova ETC, Yasin OV (1998) The morphology of the body and the aging process in the monitoring of populations posemeynom. Year Book: Ecologic Anthropology. Minsk, 93-94.
- Prokofieva-Belgovskaya AA, Kuznetsova SM (1982) Chromosomal polymorphism and longevity phenomenon in different regions of the USSR. Longevity phenomenon, Moscow, Russia.
- Voitenko VP, Akhaladze NG (1996) Human biological age and methods of its assessment. Treatment and Diagnosis 2: 45-48.
- Kuznetsova SM, Kudritskaya OV (1989) Brain bioelectric activity in aging. Z Gerontol 22: 222-227.
- Kuznetsova SM (1989) Regional-ethnic and genealogical characteristics of longevity and cerebral vascular pathology in old age: Dissertation Thesis for a Doctoral Science degree, Kiev, Ukraine.
- Yanovich LA, Kuznetsova SM (1991) National-ethnic peculiarities of aging and age-related pathology. In: Book-Collection ‘Life expectancy, Mechanisms, Prognoses, Ways of its Increase. The All-Union Conference, Kiev, Ukraine.
- Gvozdev VA, Usakin LA, Kogan GL (2003) Heterochromatin and its functional characteristics. Med Genet 7: 290-296.
- Kuznetsova S (1987) Polymorphism of geterochromatin areas on chromosomes 1, 9, 16 and Y in long-lived subjects and persons of different ages in two regions of the Soviet Union. Arch Gerontol Geriatr 6: 177-186.
- Shabalin V (2014) The psychology of longevity. J Health Care in the Russian Federation 58.
- Ailshire JA, Beltran-Sanchez H, Crimmins EM (2015) Becoming centenarians: disease and functioning trajectories of older US adults as they survive to 100. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci 2: 193-201.
- Tucker AM, Stern Y (2014) Cognitive reserve and the aging brain. In: Nair AK, Sabbagh MN (eds.). Geriatric Neurology, John Wiley & Online, USA. Pg no: 118-125.
- Frolkis VV (1991) Brain aging. Leningrad, Nauka, Moscow, Russia.
- Cevenini E, Cotichini R, Stazi MA, Toccacrli V, Scurti M, et al. (2013) How to classify the oldest old according to their health status: a study on 1160 subjects belonging to 552 90+ Italian sib-ships characterized by familial longevity recruited within the GEHA EU Project. Mech Ageing Dev 134: 560-569.
- Nair AK, Sabbagh MN (2014) Geriatric Neurology. John Wiley & Sons, USA. Pg No: 730.
- Bezrukov VV, Kuznetsova SM, Kasumov CY (2015) Biological mechanisms of longevity phenomenon. Bulletin of Medical Center for Management of the Affairs of the President of Kazakhstan the Republic, Special Issue 58: 51.
- Jansen SW, Roelfsema F, van der Spoel E, Akintola AA et al (2015) Familial longevity is associated with higher TSH secretion and strong TSH-fT3 relationship. J ClinEndocrinol Metab 100: 3806-3813.
- Cevenini E, Cotichini R, Stazi MA, Toccacrli V, Palmas MG, et al. (2014). Health status and 6 years survival of 552 90+ Italian sib-ships recruited within the EU Project GEHA (Genetics of Healthy Ageing). Age (Dordr) 36: 949-966.
- Schneider JA, Yang C, (2014) Functional Changes Associated with the Aging Nervous System. In: Nair AK, Sabbagh MN (eds.). Geriatric Neurology, John Wiley & Sons, USA. Pg no: 38-70.
- Abbasova FY, Aliyeva EM (2013) Manual, Baku, Azerbaijan.
- ?smayilova M (2013) Klimakterik sindrom zaman? ba? ver?n metabolik pozuntalar?n diagnostikas?, korreksiyas? v? profilaktikas?: Author’s Thesis. Baku 23.
- Rahilly-Tierney C R, Spiro A, Vokonas P, Gaziano JM (2011) Relation between high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and survival to age 85 years in men (from the VA normative aging study). Am J Cardiol 107: 1173-1177.
- Koridze M, Khukhunaishvili R, Nagervadze M, Zosidze N, Charkviani I (2009) Biogerontologic study of population in some districts of Ajara Autonomous Republic. Georgian Med News 171: 53-55.
- Podkolzin AA, Megreladze AG, Dontsov VI, Arutyunov SD, Mrikaeva OM, Zhukova EA (2000) System of human antioxidant defense and ageing. Prophylaxis of Ageing 3: 13-20.
- Sadowska-Bartosz I, BartoszG (2014) Effect of antioxidants. Supplementation on aging and longevity. BioMed Research International: 17.
- Flachsbart F, Franke A, Kleindorp R, Caliebe A, Blanche H, et al. (2010) Investigation of genetic susceptibility factors for human longevity - a targeted nonsynonymous SNP study. Mutat Res 694: 13-19.
- Nygaard M, Debrabant B, Tan Q, Deelen J, Andersen-Ranberg K, et al. (2016) Copy number variation associates with mortality in long-lived individuals: a genome-wide assessment. Aging Cell 15: 49-55.
Citation:Kuznetsova SM, Kamilova NM, Kuznetsov VV (2016) Mechanisms of Longevity Phenomenon in Azerbaijan. J Gerontol Geriatr Med 2: 011.
Copyright: © 2016 Kuznetsova SM, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.