Predicting Population Status of Gum and Resin Bearing Plant Species from Size Distributions in Benishangul-Gumuz Regional State, Ethiopia: Inferences for Their Sustainable Management

Ethiopia owns one of the extensive forest vegetation resources in the Horn of Africa. Ethiopia’s forest vegetation resources are classified into six broad categories, namely, forestlands, woodlands, shrublands, bushlands, plantations and bamboos [1]. Together, these forest vegetation resources cover some 50% of the 1.12 million km² total landmass of the country. The share of high forest, however, is only 3.5% whereas, woodland, shrubland and bushland combined contribute about 45% of the landmass, indicating that the latter cover quite extensive areas and ecosystems [2]. Recent studies, re-grouped the vegetation resources of Ethiopia into 12 types [3]. 

Seven of these vegetation types are encountered in drier lowland areas of the country and are commonly referred to as dry forests [4]. Combretum-Terminalia, broad-leaved deciduous dry forests and Acacia-Commiphora, small- leaved woodlands, are the two most prominent dry forest vegetation resources in the lowlands, both socio-economically and ecologically [5,6]. 

The current study targeted the Combretum-Terminalia woodland in the northwestern lowlands of the country. According to Awas [7], the Combretum-Terminalia vegetation is distributed in the northern, northwestern, western, southwestern and central parts of Ethiopia. The Combretum-Terminalia forest formations are key ecological components of several major landscapes of Ethiopia, including the Blue Nile River Basin, and support unique native biodiversity [7,8]. These forest resources are known to harbour diverse high-value woody species, such as those that produce commercial gums and resins [4,5]. In Ethiopia, 21 Commiphora, 6 Boswellia, 12 Acacia and 3 Sterculia species have been identified so far as major sources and/or adulterants of commercial gums and resins [5,9-11]. 

Major gums and resins of international commerce produced and traded in and from Ethiopia include frankincense from various Boswellia species; gum Arabic, gum gumero and gum talha from Acacia species; and myrrh, opopanax and hagar from Commiphora species [9]. In addition, recent studies reported existing opportunities to produce trade volume of gum karaya from Sterculia species in different parts of the country [5,10,11]. Professional estimates show that Ethiopia has over 3.5 million ha of woodlands and bushlands with an estimated annual production potential of 270,000 tons of gums and resins [4]. 

Despite the diverse woody species harbored by the Combretum-Terminalia and Acacia-Commiphora vegetation resources and their huge socio-economic and ecological importance, these resources are under increasing anthropogenic and natural pressures [8,12,13]. This has resulted in severe degradation of habitats, soil and water resources as well as decline of biodiversity in the drylands of the country where these resources are common. According to Lemenih, et al., until recently very little attention has been given to develop, protect and sustainably manage these valuable resources [4]. Instead, Rahmato argued that there is a massive transformation of forestland into farmlands in the Combretum-Terminalia woodland belt, ignoring the various socio-economic and ecological benefits that can be obtained through sustainable management and conservation of the forest vegetation [14]. Experts, thus, worry that such massive conversion of forestland to other land uses might lead to irreversible damage to these ecosystems. 

Various current professional discussions indicate that the growing pressure on dry forest resources is partly due to inadequate or, in some cases, complete lack of comprehensive scientific information and knowledge on the status of current stock and dynamics of the plant populations housed in these vegetation resources. A good example is the Benishangul-Gumuz National Regional State (BGNRS) in western Ethiopia. This region is one of the major frankincense belts of the country. However, little is known about the diversity, abundance, distribution and dynamics of the gum- and resin- bearing and associated woody species in the region. Hence, while concerted efforts of the relevant government and non-government organizations to integrate the currently marginalized forest resources into the overall rural development planning is a key step forward, in-depth scientific investigations on the status of plant populations of these resources are of paramount importance. Apparently, available information suggests that production of non- timber forest products, such as gums and resins, would help to promote a better integration of dry forests and, thereby, enhance economic productivity along with environmental conservation in these fragile ecosystems [9,10]. 

The objective of this study was to provide empirical information on the diversity, abundance, population structures and status of natural regeneration of gum- and resin-producing woody species in BGNRS. This will contribute to the ongoing efforts of generating basic information nation-wide on the status of dry forests and woodlands and develop suitable management models that can facilitate their integration into the planning process of agricultural development and re-settlement programme in the country.

Study area 

The Benishangul-Gumuz National Regional State shares common borders with the Amhara National Region State in the north and east, the Sudan in the northwest and the Oromia National Region State in the south (Figure 1). It is divided into three administrative zones, namely, Metekel, Kamashi and Assosa, and a total of 19 districts. Metekel is the largest zone with an area of 26,272 km² followed by Asosa (14,166 km²). The altitude of BGNRS ranges from 600 m.a.s.l. in areas bordering the Sudan to over 2500 m [7], and about 75% of the land is below 1500 m, traditionally referred to as kola (literally ‘dry and hot’). The average annual temperatures are between 20 and 25°C. During the hottest months (between January and May), they range between 28 and 34°C. The annual rainfall ranges between 500 and 1800 mm and is spread through May to October. 

The number of vascular plants in BGNRS is estimated at 1,102 species, with 28 of them being endemic to Ethiopia [7]. The forests and woodlands are characterized by small- to moderate-sized trees and shrubs. According to Awas, the region is one of the few areas in Ethiopia selected by the Government as development corridor for rain-fed and irrigated commercial farming [7].

 Figure 1: Map of Ethiopia showing Benishangul-Gumuz National Regional State and the two study districts. 

The human population of the BGNRS was estimated at 670,847 in 2007 [15], of which 90% live in rural areas, indicating a very low level of urbanization in the region [7]. In addition to the introduction of commercial farming, there is an increase in human and livestock populations in the region that could also lead to additional pressure on the wellbeing of the plant communities and the ecosystem. 

The study was carried out in one administrative zone, namely, Assosa. The Berta ethnic group dominate Assosazone. This zone is known to support extensive dry forest resources that harbour gum- and resin-producing species. Two districts, Sherkoleand Kurmuk were randomly selected from the lists of districts in the zone. According to the 2007 national census, the total population of Sherkole was 19,992 with a population density of 7.8 persons per km² and that of Kurmuk was 14,907 with 3.8 inhabitants per km² [15]. The altitudes of the two districts range between 500 and 1500 m asl [1]. According to Awas, altitude is the most important environmental gradient determining species distribution in the region [7]. Both districts receive mean annual rainfall ranging between 900 and 1200 mm and experience six months of dry season. The mean annual temperature ranges between 20 and 27.5°C. In each district, a 5 km x 5 km site was chosen for data collection. In the following, ‘Sherkole’ refers to the Sherkole study site, and ‘Kurmuk’ refers to the Kurmuk study site. 

Data collection 

As there is no sufficient vegetation map for the study areas, an ocular boundary demarcation technique was used to approximately delineate the boundaries of the vegetation types [16]. This was carried out based on existing topographic map and the intensive reconnaissance survey carried out to roughly delineate the distribution of the vegetation in the study districts. Additional inputs were also obtained from local experts and knowledgeable rural people. The information from these sources indicated that most parts of the study districts were uniform in terms of the overall vegetation distribution and structure. The study areas house Combretum-Terminalia woodland in which Boswellia and Sterculia species are also found. Further, the topography of most parts of the districts is also uniform. Based on these observations, 21 transects (10 in Sherkole and 11 in Kurmuk), with variable lengths, were laid along a 566 to 1400 m asl altitudinal gradient. The first transect line was randomly laid and the rest were set at an interval of 500 m from each other. The variations in the length of transect lines resulted from inaccessibility of some parts of the forest and encountering other land uses, e.g. gold mining and crop farmingareas. 

A total of 118 (20 m x 20 m) sample plots (61 in Kurmuk and 57 in Sherkole) were laid along the transect lines, following the procedures described by [16]. In each plot, the identity, number of individuals, Diameter at Breast Height (DBH) and height of all woody species having a height above 1.5 m were recorded. Sub-plots of 5mx5m wereas used for woody species inventory. Individuals with heights of 1.5 m were considered as seedlings, counted and recorded [5]. DBH and height were measured using a diameter tape and hypsometer, respectively. In addition, discussions were held with local experts, rural knowledgeable persons and companies engaged in the export of gums and resins to get insights about the status of gum and resin collection and trade in the region in general and at the study zones in particular.

Data analyses 

Diversity of all gum and resin bearing species was determined using the Shannon - Wiener Diversity Index (H) and Evenness (E) [16]. Jaccard’s Similarity Coefficient (Sj) was used to compute similarity in woody species composition of the two districts. The indices were computed using the following formulas:

H = - ∑^s_i=1P_ilnP_i

Where H is Shannon - Wiener diversity index and  P_i  is the proportion of individuals found in the i^th species;

E_H=H/Hmax= H/lnS

Where E is evenness, H_max is the maximum level of diversity possible within a given population, which equals ln (number of species); and

J=C/(A+B+C)

Where J is Jaccard’s similarity coefficient, C is the number of species common to both sites, A is the number of species present in one of the sites to be compared and B is the number of species present in the other site. 

Density was calculated by converting the total number of individuals of each species to equivalent numbers per hectare (absolute density), and as the percentage of the absolute density of each species divided by the total stem number of all species ha²¹ (relative density). Frequency distribution of each species was determined from the number of plots in which the species was recorded (absolute frequency) [16], and as a percentage (relative frequency) by dividing the absolute frequency of the species by the sum of the absolute frequencies of all the species. The absolute dominance of woody species with DBH 2.5 cm was determined from summing the Basal Area (BA) of all individuals of a species. Relative dominance was calculated as the percentage of the BA of a species divided by the total BA of all species. 

The relative ecological importance of each woody species, commonly referred to as Important Value Index (IVI), was determined by summing its relative frequency, relative density and relative dominance [16]. 

The population structures and status of natural regeneration of the entire woody vegetation and that of gum- and resin- bearing woody species was assessed from the frequency distribution of diameters based on histograms constructed by grouping all individuals of each woody species into the following successive diameter classes: 1 = 0 -10, 2 = 10 - 20, 3 = 20 - 30, 4 = 30 - 40 and 5 = 40 cm [17-19].

Species richness

In total, six species, namely, Acacia seyal, Acacia senegal, Acacia polyacantha, Boswellia papyrifera, Commiphora africana and Sterculia africana were identified as sources of commercial gums and resins. Fabaceae isthe family that encompasses the two gum and resin bearing species.

Diversity, evenness and similarity 

The diversity (H) values of gum- and resin-bearing woody species were 0.46 and 0.86, respectively.

Density, frequency and dominance 

The densities of gum- and resin-bearing woody species accounted for 29% and 50% of the total density values at Sherkole and Kurmuk, respectively. Few of the species dominated the woody vegetation and exhibited higher frequency values. At Sherkole, S. africana and B. papyrifera were the two relatively abundant gum- and resin- bearing species (Table 1). However, A. seyal and C. africana were represented with few individuals. Among the gum- and resin-bearing species, A. polyacantha, A. seyal and B. papyrifera showed a relatively abundant representation. In contrast, S. setigera and A. senegal were the least abundant gum- and resin-bearing species. 

Table 1: List of gum and resin bearing species encountered in the Kurmukand Sherkole study plots in descending order of IVI values.

Note: DE ¼ absolute density (ha²¹), RDE ¼ relative density (%), FR ¼ absolute frequency (%), RFR ¼ relative frequency (%), DO ¼ absolute dominance (m²), RDO ¼ relative dominance (%) and IVI ¼ Importance Value Index

B. papyrifera and S. africana were the most frequent gum- and resin-bearing species at Sherkole with 66% and 59% frequency values, respectively. C. africana and A. seyal were the least frequent gum- and resin-bearing species at Sherkole. At Kurmuk, S. africana (frequency ¼ 35%), A. polyacantha (frequency ¼ 33%) and B. papyrifera (frequency ¼ 32%) were relatively the most frequent gum- and resin-bearing species compared with the least frequent species, namely A. senegal (frequency, 11%) and A. seyal (frequency, 9%). B. papyrifera, S. africana and A. seyal were common to both sites while C. africana was recorded only in plots at Sherkole and A. senegal and A. polyacantha only in plots at Kurmuk.

Importance value index 

The Importance Value Index (IVI) values of all the woody species ranged between 4.28 (C. africana) and 67 (B. papyrifera) at the two districts (Table 1). The gum- and resin-bearing woody species accounted for 37% and 50% of the total IVI values at Sherkole and Kurmuk, respectively (Table 1).

Population structure and status of natural regeneration 

The population structures of gum and resin bearing species at both sites exhibited an ‘inverted-J’ shaped frequency distribution of diameter classes. In Kurmuk, in particular, the diameter distribution of gum- and resin-bearing species showed clear ‘inverted-J’ shape with larger number of individuals in smaller diameter classes and, to a lesser extent, a decline in abundance in the next diameter classes. However, the contribution of gum- and resin bearing species to the sapling population of the entire woody species was higher at Kurmuk (21%) compared with Sherkole (13%), where S. africana, B. papyrifera, A. seyal and C. africana were among the major contributors. 

The gum- and resin- bearing woody species can be categorized into three groups based on the patterns exhibited by their population structures. The first group exhibited an inverted ‘J’ shaped population structure, where higher numbers of individuals were observed at the lowest diameter classes and progressively declining numbers of individuals with increasing diameter classes. This pattern of population structure indicates stable or healthy regeneration of the species. Acacia senegal, A. polyacantha, A. seyal and C. africana belonged to this group. The second group represents a bell-shaped diameter distribution demonstrated by B. papyrifera at both study districts. The third type of population structure was a ‘J’ shaped diameter class frequency distribution exhibited by S. africana in Sherkole district (Figures 2 and 3). In fact, S. africana depicted an inverted ‘J’ shaped diameter distribution in Sherkole district. In general, the latter two patterns of population structures indicate unhealthy or hampered regeneration profiles.  

Figure 2: Diameter class frequency distribution of gum and resin bearing tree species from Kurmuk (diameter class: 1 = 0 - 10, 2 = 10 - 20, 3 = 20 - 30, 4 = 30 - 40 and 5 = 40 cm).

Figure 3: Diameter class frequency distribution of gum and resin bearing tree species from Guba (diameter class: 1 = 0 - 10, 2 = 10 - 20, 3 = 20 - 30, 4 = 30 - 40 and 5 = 40 cm).

Generally, species richness, abundance, dominance, frequency and IVI describe the floristic characteristics of an area. The numbers of woody plant species recorded at the study sites (18 at Sherkole and 23 at Kurmuk) are comparable to those reported from Abergele, northern Ethiopia (22 spp.; Eshete, et al. [5]) and Yabello, southern Ethiopia (23 spp.; Worku, et al. [12]), where gum- and resin-bearing species are also common. 

However, the species richness values at the current study sites are far lower than those reported from Combretum-Terminalia forests in Metema, northern Ethiopia (78 spp.; Adamu, et al. [20]) and Acacia-Commiphora woodlands in Arero, southern Ethiopia (41 spp.; Worku, et al. [12]). On the other hand, Sherkole and Guba are relatively floristically richer than Upper Rift Valley areas where only six woody species were encountered in the established quadrates [21]. Gebrehiwot also reported fewer species (13 woody spp.) in Boswellia-dominated dry woodlands in selected areas of northern Ethiopia [22]. 

In terms of gum- and resin-bearing woody species, BGNRS houses lesser number of species than that of Borana, southern Ethiopia, where 18 gum- and resin-bearing species were reported in the Acacia-Commiphora vegetation even from lesser number of sample plots [12]. Similarly, the Acacia-Commiphora dry forests of South Omo Zone houses 15 gum- and resin-bearing species [11]. Nonetheless, the study sites support a comparable number of gum- and resin-bearing woody species to those reported from dry forests/woodlands in northern (nine species), central (two species) and southeastern (seven species) parts of Ethiopia where similar assessment methods were employed [5,9,21,22]. 

Gum- and resin-bearing species have considerable significance at both study sites based on their density, frequency, dominance and IVI. For instance, at Sherkole, 29% of B. papyrifera contributes up to 90% of Ethiopia’s annual gum and resin trade volume, implying the great importance of this species. In contrast, existing unhealthy population demography of the species across all its natural growing ranges, including the current study areas, implies that the country at large and rural livelihoods that depend on this species for a considerable proportion of their annual income and the many export companies, in particular, may lose their income in the future. In other words, frankincense production from B. papyrifera may not be sustainable. 

S. africana showed different population structures at the two study sites, i.e. stable and hampered regeneration in Kurmuk and Sherkole, respectively. Also, its density is four times higher in Kurmuk than in Sherkole. In Sherkole, a large number of individuals of this species belong to the highest diameter class, i.e. old trees, with very low or no chance of being replaced when they die. This pattern clearly indicates hampered regeneration, which might have been caused by poor seed production of the species due to old age or other environmental problems as well as poor seedling and sapling recruitment, e.g. due to heavy grazing by animals [23]. Discussions with key informants revealed that domestic and wild animals browse the seedlings of most gum-and resin- bearing species. Field level observations and discussions with local experts also revealed that Kurmuk is harsher in terms of temperature than Sherkole and, hence, that more people are engaged in livestock production. It is a common practice in the study area, and elsewhere in Ethiopia, to let livestock graze in forests. Local experts also argued that since the district is relatively scarcely populated, there are more wild herbivores. More domestic and wild herbivores in Sherkole than in Kurmuk may, thus, have contributed to the hampered regeneration of some woody species. Local experts also mentioned the prevalence of more soil degradation in Sherkole district. In general, the woody species categorized in the second and third group require special attention to address their hampered regeneration. As mentioned in the introductory part of this article [14], BGNRS has become one of the few regions targeted by government led re-settlement and commercial farming. In some areas in the region, there is a growing influx of human and livestock population, adding pressure on the natural landscapes and reproduction of forest trees now and in the future. The key informants also mentioned the increasing negative effects of climate change and variability, and forest fire risks along with deforestation due to land use changes during the past few decades. 

Our results revealed that BGNRS is among the regions known to support extensive forest resources dominated by gum- and resin- producing woody species. Our discussions with local people, experts and export companies of gums and resins about the production of gums and resins in the study areas revealed that, unlike the Amhara and Tigray National Regional States, a few companies are engaged in the production, processing and export of gums and resins in BGNRS. The Natural Gum Processing and Marketing Enterprise, which is the major parasternal gum and resin export company, and a few private companies out of the over 30 nationally licensed gum and resin export companies produce, process and export, mainly, frankincense but also gum Arabic in BGNRS, including in the study areas. According to local natural resource experts, such a lower representation of major actors from the central marketing system is a serious bottleneck to demonstrate the socio-economic significance of the gum and resin resources in the region. Despite the inadequate number of export companies, Alemu, et al. reported that more than 300 tons of frankincense and gum Arabic, worth 0.6 million USD, were collected, processed and exported form the BGNRS in 2011 [24]. This implies the importance of BGNRS for enhancing gum and resin commercialization and, thereby, promoting integrated management of the dry forests rather than changing them to other land uses. 

Further, Worku, et al. emphasized that if managed well and integrated with other production systems, existing populations of gum- and resin- producing woody species in the region will offer opportunities for the local communities to access additional incomes [12]. Although not well-organized, the local communities in BGNRS are also engaged in the collection and sale of gums and resins as individuals and, in some areas, co-operatives. The current participation in and benefits of local households from gums and resins would be further enhanced both by establishing new strong co-operatives and strengthening existing ones as well as connecting them with market outlets. As elaborated in various reports [12,25], organizing the local communities to benefit from the gum and resin trade will enhance ownership and responsible management of the rampantly degrading Combretum-Terminalia forest vegetation in this part of Ethiopia.

Further comparatives studies, mainly in areas of regeneration that could be based on dry and wet seasons, exploration of diversity, estimation of gum and resins productivity of the woody species and the overall socio-economic aspects of the forest resources is needed. There is also a need for research to develop a feasible model that will facilitate strategic integration of dry forests into the current national developmental planning, as an alternative to large scale re-settlements and commercial farming programmes that are proliferating in BGNRS. Research has also to develop options to link the gum- and- resin producing forests to the current climate-related funds, such as REDD +þ and other opportunities.

We are grateful to the regional experts, the local administration and people who supported and facilitated the field data collection. We would like to thank the Ethiopian Biodiversity Institute Assosa Center for the financial and facility support. We also acknowledge gratefully the anonymous reviewer for the valuable comments on an earlier version of this article.

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

1. Woody Biomass Inventory and Strategic Planning Project (WBISPP) (2005) Forest resources of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development.
2. FAO(2010) Guideline on sustainable forest management in drylands of Sub-Saharan Africa. Arid Zone Forest and Forestry Working Paper No. 1. Rome: FAO.
3. Friis I, Demissew S, Breugel P (2010) Atlas of the potential vegetation of Ethiopia. Copenhagen: The Royal Danish Academy of Sciences and Letters.
4. Lemenih M, Kassa H (2011) Opportunities and challenges for sustainable production and marketing of gums and resins in Ethiopia. Bogor: CIFOR, pp: 1-93.
5. Eshete A, Sterck F, Bongers F (2011) Diversity and production of Ethiopian dry woodlands explained by climate- and soil-stress gradients. Forest Ecol Manage 261: 1499-1509.
6. Groenendijk P, Eshete A, Sterck FJ, Zuidema PA, Bongers F (2012) Limitations to sustainable frankincense production: blocked regeneration, high adult mortality and declining populations. J Appl Ecol 49: 164-173.
7. Awas T (2007) Plant diversity in Western Ethiopia: ecology, ethnobotany and conservation. University of Oslo, pp: 1-39.
8. Teketay D (2004) Causes and consequences of dryland forest degradation in Sub-Saharan Africa. Walia 24: 3-20.
9. Lemenih M, Abebe T, Olsson M (2003) Gum and Resin resources from some Acacia, Boswellia and Commiphora species and their economic contributions in Liban, South-East Ethiopia. J Arid Environ 55: 465- 482.
10. Worku A, Lemenih M, Fetene M, Teketay D (2011) Socio-economic importance of gum and resin resources in the dry woodlands of Borana, southern Ethiopia. Forests, Trees and Livelihoods 20: 137-155.
11. Adem M, Worku A, Lemenih M, Tadesse W, Pretzsch J (2014) Diversity, regeneration status and population structure of gum- and resin-bearing woody species in south omo zone, southern Ethiopia. J Forestry Res 25: 319-328.
12. Worku A, Teketay D, Lemenih M, Fetene M (2012) Diversity, regeneration status, and population structures of gum- and resin-producing woody species in Borana, Southern Ethiopia. J Forests, Trees and Livelihoods iFirst article: 1-12.
13. Lemenih M, Bongers F (2011) Dry forests of Ethiopia and their silviculture. In: Gunter S, Weber M, Stimm B, Mosandi R (Eds.). Silviculture in the Tropics. Berlin Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, pp: 261-272.
14. Rahmato D (2011) Land to investor: large-scale land transfers in Ethiopia. Addis Ababa: Forum for Social Studies, pp: 1-36.
15. Central Statistics Agency (CSA) (2007) Population and housing census report. Addis Ababa: Ethiopia.
16. Kent M, Coker P (1992) Vegetation description and analysis: a practical approach. London: John Wiley & Sons.
17. Peters M (1996) The ecology and management of non-timber forest resources. World Bank Technical Paper 322, Washington.
18. Teketay D (1997) Seedling populations and regeneration of woody species in dry Afromontane forests of Ethiopia. Forest Ecol Manage 98: 149-165.
19. Ogbazghi W, Rijkers T, Wessel M, Bongers F (2006) Distribution of the frankincense tree Boswellia papyrifera in Eritrea: the role of environment and land use. J Biogeography 33: 524-535.
20. Adamu H, Bekele T, Dalle G (2012) Floristic diversity, regeneration status, and vegetation structure of woodlands in Metema area, Amhara national regional state, Northwestern Ethiopia. J Forestry Res 23: 391-398.
21. Argaw M, Teketay D, Olsson M (1999) Soil seed flora, germination and regeneration pattern of woody species in an Acacia woodland of the Rift Valley in Ethiopia. J Arid Environ. 43: 411-435.
22. Gebrehiwot K (2003) Ecology and regeneration of Boswellia papyrifera in dry forest of Tigray, North Ethiopia Gottingen: Georg-August University.
23. Teketay D, Lemenih M, Bekele T, Yemshaw Y, Feleke F, et al. (2010) Forest resources and challenges of sustainable forest management and conservation in Ethiopia. In: Bongers F, Tennigkeit T (Eds.). Degraded forests in Eastern Africa: management and restoration (1^st). London: Earthscan.
24. Alemu A, Eshetu Z, Garedew E, Kassa H (2015) Assessment of vegetation characteristics and production of Boswellia papyrifera woodlands in north western lowlands of Ethiopia. Sky J Agric Res. 4: 8-13.
25. Woldeamanuel T (2011) Dryland resources, livelihoods and institutions: diversity and dynamics in use and management of gum and resin trees in Ethiopia. Wageningen University.