Retained intraorbital organic foreign bodies most often present acutely with significant inflammatory or infectious sequalae necessitating surgical removal [1]. We present a 65-year-old woman who was evaluated for an upper lid lesion that she noticed one and a half years ago which subsequently became inflamed three-to-four weeks prior to presentation. A one cm-long green plant stem was excised from a superior orbital tract, after which the patient recovered without symptoms. Upon further discussion with the patient, she noted that she had fallen three years earlier and believed that the initial embedding of the plant material occurred during this fall. After her fall, the patient developed binocular diplopia that lasted for about two months and then resolved spontaneously. This is the first known case of retained intraorbital organic foreign body that initially presented with symptoms, resolved, and subsequently presented years later with different symptoms, leading to the discovery of the foreign body.