Journal of Psychiatry Depression & Anxiety Category: Clinical Type: Original Research
Life Satisfaction and Correlates among Working Women of a Tertiary Care Health Sector: A Cross Sectional Study from Delhi
- Mamta Parashar1, Mitasha Singh2*, Panna Lal3, Rambha Pathak1
- 1 Department Of Community Medicine, Hamdard Institute Of Medical Sciences And Research, New Delhi, India
- 2 Department Of Community Medicine, ESIC Medical College And Hospital, Faridabad, India
- 3 Department Of Community Medicine, Baba Saheb Ambedkar Medical College And Hospital, New Delhi, India
*Corresponding Author:Mitasha Singh
Department Of Community Medicine, ESIC Medical College And Hospital, Faridabad, India
Received Date: Jun 06, 2017 Accepted Date: Sep 01, 2017 Published Date: Sep 15, 2017
The dual role of women at home and workplace negatively impacts their quality of life. The health care system demands quality services and urbanization and globalization has increased the demands of every individual to lead a satisfactory life.
To find out the correlates of life satisfaction among working women of health sector.
A descriptive cross sectional study was conducted among women staff in campus of a tertiary care centre of New Delhi for a period of six months (2011-2012). A sample of 345 women was selected with equal representation from all departments of the institution. All participants were asked to complete modified pretested semi-structured Life Satisfaction Scale by Alam and Srivastava.
Prevalence of overall satisfaction among working females in our study was 39.3%. Females were highly satisfied with their job but satisfaction level in Health and economic domain was low. Age, type of occupation, mode of transport, family type and income as compared to husband were the significant correlates of satisfaction level in different domains.
Satisfaction being a subjective feeling will only be attained in all domains once the stressors of life are reduced.
Study design and study population
She had been regularly attending the antenatal consultations with no risk factors identified. Her prenatal laboratory results were unremarkable except for GBS-unknown. She had three normal obstetric ultrasounds (one of each trimester); her blood type was A+. Pregnancy was uneventful with no history of vomiting, blood loss or abdominal trauma.
On admission at the delivery unit, the obstetric ultrasound revealed no fetal movements with the presence of heart beat. The Cardiotocograph (CTG) was not tranquilizing as it showed prolonged deceleration and reduced variability with pathological trace that suggested a sinusoidal pattern and, as a result, an emergent caesarean section was performed (Figure 1).A baby boy was born weighing 2610g. The newborn had a circular of the umbilical cord around the arms. On examination at birth, he was markedly pale and hypotonic with respiratory depression. Orothracheal intubation and connection to mechanical ventilation was immediately performed. He responded well and was extubated 4 minutes after and transferred to the neonatal unit with oxygen directly to his face, for further evaluation and management. The Apgar score was 5/8/8.
Initial blood gas from the umbilical cord revealed pH 7.27, pCO2 50.6 mm Hg, Hemoglobin 4.4, g/dL, bicarbonate 21.9 mmol/L and lactates 5.8 mmol/L. Laboratory exams revealed 4.0 g/dL of hemoglobin, white blood cell count of 47.700/10 EXP 9/L with 22.7% neutrophils (10.800), platelets count 183.000/10 EXP 9/L, DHL 680 UI/L, CK 190 UI/L. Further laboratory evaluation was unchanged (bilirubin, cardiac enzymes and C reactive protein). Coombs test and viral serology for Parvovirus B19 and Cytomegalovirus were negative. Hemoglobin electrophoresis showed a presence of 5% fetal hemoglobin on mother’s blood. Kleihauer-Betke test was performed, since it is a more specific exam and quantifies the amount of blood transfusion. It revealed 17.8% of fetal red cells in maternal circulation, which corresponds to a volume of approximately 890 mL of fetal blood based on the formula: (% of fetal cells determined by Kleihauer-Betke test/100) X 5000 mL = volume of FMH (in mL)  and also according to the fact that 1% of fetal erythrocytes in maternal circulation is equivalent to a fetal hemorrhage of 50mL .
Two red blood cell transfusions were made and at 12 hours of life his hemoglobin was 13.3 g/dL, white blood cells count of 10.100/uL (Neutrophils: 64.4%), platelets count of 219.000/uL and erythroblasts 87/100 leucocytes.
The outcome was favorable with hemodynamic and respiratory stability and absence of abnormal movements. Cranial ultrasonography showed, in the 3rd day of life, frontal bilateral parenchymal hyperechogenicity, was not present on 11th day of life as the ultrasounds were made by two different physicians. The authors admit that the hyperechogenicity have not been valorized by the second physician.
Follow-up at 2 and 4 months revealed a normal physical and neurological examination.
Ethical clearance permission
The semi-structured questionnaire included 2 sections:
1. Demographic profile: It contained information on age, sex, education, occupation, income of the respondent.
2. Adapted version of modified Life Satisfaction Scale (L.S.S) - Alam and Srivastava including questions on various domain of life satisfaction
The fifty items related to five areas of life viz. Health, Personal, Economic, Social and Job was taken from the scale. Satisfaction in each of the domains’ responses were scored using five-point Likert’s scale with responses including; always, most of the time, sometimes, rarely, never. Where positive responses were expected, scores of 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 were given for always, most of the time, sometimes, rarely and never responses respectively. On the other hand, in questions where negative responses were expected, scores of 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 were given for never, rarely, sometimes, most of the time and always responses respectively. The scores in each of the domain were added up and the minimum and maximum score was identified. Thereafter, for each study participant each domain’s total score was used to calculate percentage scores.
The adapted version was pretested on 25 random adult working females who were not from the same study area. Any discrepancy and difficulty faced was dealt with by the experts of the domain.
The study purpose was explained to all eligible participants and informed consent was obtained from all who were willing to participate. In case the selected participants did not match inclusion criteria, the next available staff was approached. The interns posted in our department distributed the questionnaires to the eligible participants and get it filled in their working places. After collecting the questionnaires they were checked by investigators for completeness. Following completion, results of each participant was revealed to them.
Data and statistical analysis
The maximum mean score percentage in each domain was 100 which represent maximum level of dissatisfaction in social, economic, personal and health domains. The higher mean score in job domain represent high level of satisfaction. Overall economic dissatisfaction mean score percentage was higher as compared to other domains (64.15±14.66); job and health domains scored higher in satisfaction level. The mean percentage score of satisfaction in various domains are distributed across various socio demographic variables (Table 1).
|Total (345)||Economic||Pvalue||Personal||Pvalue||Social||Pvalue||Job||Pvalue||Health||P value|
|Age groups (years)|
|Mode of transport|
|Type of family|
|More than husband-270||58.95±10.32||<0.001||63.12±13.43||0.95||58.75±9.60||0.65||65.58±15.96||<0.001||36.25±28.72||0.87|
|Less than and equal to husband -75||82.88±12.54||63.24±12.24||59.33±10.29||54.89±16.04||36.83±25.82|
Economic and personal un-satisfaction was observed to be significantly (p<0.01) higher among younger age groups (18-30 years). Middle aged females (31-45 years) reported significantly higher level of job satisfaction as compared to other groups (p<0.001). Economic dissatisfaction increased as the mode of transport changed from private to public to walking (p<0.01). However, health dissatisfaction showed an insignificant inverse trend as the mode of transport changed from private to public to walking. Social dissatisfaction among study participants showed a significant distribution with occupation (p: 0.02). It was observed to be highest among unskilled workers and less among skilled staff. Personal and economic un-satisfaction was observed to be highest among skilled and professional staff as compared to other groups (p<0.01). Marital status otherwise did not have significant effect on any of the domains of satisfaction. A significantly higher mean percentage satisfaction was observed in personal and job domain among those who lived in nuclear families (p<0.001). Participants from joint families however, reported a higher social satisfaction (p: 0.03) but dissatisfaction in other domains compared to those from nuclear families. Participants who had children reported a lower level of un-satisfaction in economic and higher personal dissatisfaction as compared to those who did not have. Income equal to husband gave a higher economic dissatisfaction (p<0.001) and higher job satisfaction (p<0.001) to the participants as compared to those with higher income than husband (Table 1).
A further analysis using post hoc Tukey’s HSD analysis on independent variables with significant ANOVA results in different domains revealed that the pair wise significant difference was observed with higher social dissatisfaction among unskilled as compared to skilled workers (p: 0.011). Unskilled workers also scored significantly higher in economic dissatisfaction as compared to all other types of occupation groups. The pair wise difference among age groups was observed to be significant job satisfaction in higher age group as compared to middle ages and young age group (p: 0.000). Middle age workers scored significantly higher in un-satisfaction in personal domain as compared to higher age group (p: 0.032). Economic dissatisfaction was higher (p: 0.001) among younger age group (18-30 years) as compared to higher age group (46-60 years). Mode of transport and occupation did not yield any significant pair wise comparisons in personal satisfaction domain. Those preferring walking as a mode of transport scored significantly higher on economic un-satisfaction as compared to public (p: 0.028) and private transport (p: 0.008) (Table 2).
|Independent Variable Category||Independent Variable Category||Difference in Scores of Both Categories||Difference in Scores of both Categories||Difference in Scores of both Categories|
|Social Domain||Personal Domain||Economic Domain|
|Occupation type (I)||Occupation type (J)||I-J||P value||I-J||P value||I-J||P value|
|Age groups (I)||Age group (J)||I-J||P value||I-J||P value||I-J||P value|
|Mode of Transport (I)||Mode of Transport (J)||I-J||P value||I-J||P value|
Table 2: Domain wise Tukey HSD test showing effect of various factors on satisfaction of women.
Satisfaction is a way a person perceives how his or her life has been and how they feel about where it is going in the future i.e., a measure of wellbeing . Our study focused on health sector which involves odd and long working hours and dealing with human diseases and lives hence is one of the possible reasons for the higher proportion of stress in this group  The overall satisfaction scores was high in job and health domain of participants of our study. Also economic satisfaction remained the lowest. Working in a health sector gives a sense of security in terms of feasibility of health care seeking behavior. Among females medical profession is the most sought after professions and those possessing it are observed to be satisfied with it. A similar finding of higher proportion of job satisfaction was reported by health professionals of Saudi Arabia .
Across all the domains of life measured; age, type of occupation and mode of transport to and from work emerged as significant predictors of satisfaction. Lack of satisfaction may be reflected in lack of adjustment in either of the areas identified earlier herein. Young age females were economically and personally unsatisfied as compared to higher age groups. This finding was supported by women from Jammu and Kashmir and United Arab Emirates [10-14]. Age is an important moderator of effect of marital status, income, health and social support upon LS. Contrasting non significant association with age was reported by Jadhav et al., among working women from Karnataka . In our study setting scenario older and more years of experience one has; they secure a permanent or regular job. This is consistent with many studies that demonstrated that young and presumably less experienced staff has difficulties coping with the demands of work hence less satisfied [10,16-18].
An obvious level of dissatisfaction was observed among unskilled staff of health sector probably related to level of education they have attained. This may be because highly educated people tend to land better jobs with higher pay and prestige, and consequently have higher self-esteem .
Those using private vehicles for transporting to and from work reported economic high level of satisfaction as compared to those using public transport. A high level personal satisfaction was also observed but not significant in post hoc analysis. Commuting in public transport increases the level of stress due to tiredness in travelling long distances, standing for long and a constant fear of reaching safely at their destination in metropolitan cities like Delhi . Mode of transport is not an independent predictor of satisfaction. Travelling in private transport gives a sense of self esteem among those who can afford; but no significant level of satisfaction in other domains was observed.
Women who resided in joint families were satisfied socially but personally unsatisfied. Family acts as a social security and joint families have an advantage over nuclear families in sharing responsibilities hence providing higher level of social security leading to satisfaction . Joint families provide economic security to those who are dependent on earning member; but on the cost of personal and job satisfaction. To maintain a work home balance a working female in a joint family cannot look after her health leading to high level of dissatisfaction in health domain. The attempt of working women to integrate, organize and balance personal and professional responsibilities in their different roles simultaneously results in lack of satisfaction.
Those having children reported significant level of economic satisfaction but personal un-satisfaction. However, a study on US pediatricians reported higher proportion of female pediatricians with children but this was not a factor in satisfaction . Those earning more than their husbands reported significant higher economic as well as job satisfaction as they contributed more in their family and probably a higher status at workplace too.
Our study represents a small cross-section of the population confined to only working women of tertiary care health sector in a developing country, which is one of the limitations. The fact that there is no control group does compromise the results and the L-S scale though validated on Indian population was not specifically validated on working women of health sector, but the results show positive trends. Future projects with larger samples with a robust methodology representing all categories of the population are on the way.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
- Barata S, Centeno M, Marques JP, Clode N, da Graça LM (2009) Hemorragia feto-materna grave Massive feto-maternal haemorrhage. Acta Obstet Ginecol Port 3: 169-172.
- Kliegman RM (2011) Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, (19thedn). Elsevier/Saunders, USA.
- Kim YA, Makar RS (2012) Detection of fetomaternal hemorrhage. Am J Hematol 87: 417-423.
- Lobo AL, Tomás E, da Silva FP, Barbot J, Raposo T (2001) Anemia Neonatal Grave por Hemorragia Feto-Materna Caso Clínico. Acta Pediatr Port 32: 395-397.
- Zuppa AA, Scorrano A, Cota F, D’Andrea V, Francciolla A, et al. (2008) Massive fetomaternal hemorrhage and late-onset neutropenia: description of two cases. Turk J Pediatr 50: 400-404.
- Solomonia N, Playforth K, Reynolds EW (2012) Fetal-Maternal Hemorrhage: A Case and Literature Review. AJP Rep 2: 7-14.
- Dziegiel MH, Nielsen LK, Berkowicz A (2006) Detecting fetomaternal hemorrhage by flow cytometry. Curr Opin Hematol 13: 490-495.
- Kecskes Z (2003) Large fetomaternal hemorrhage: clinical presentation and outcome. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 13:128-132.
- Diener ED (1994) Assessing subjective well-being: Progress and opportunities. Social Indicators Research 31: 103-157.
- Crump C, Winkleby MA, Sundquist K, Sundquist J (2013) Comorbidities and mortality in persons with schizophrenia: a Swedish national cohort study. Am J Psychiatry 170: 324-333.
- Rauma PH, Koivumaa-Honkanen H, Williams LJ, Tuppurainen MT, Kroger HP, et al. (2014) Life satisfaction and bone mineral density among postmenopausal women: cross-sectional and longitudinal associations. Psychosom Med 76: 709-715.
- Diener E, Emmon RA, Larsen RJ, Griffin S (1985) The satisfaction with life scale. J Per Asses 49: 71-75.
- Shin DC, Johnson DM (1978) Avowed Happiness as an Overall Assessment of the Quality of Life. Social Indicators Research 5: 475-492.
- Kausha M, Moheen N (1997) Predictors of Life Satisfaction among Urban Iranian Women: An Exploratory Analysis. Social Indicators Research 40: 329-357
- Chaudhary A (2015) A Study of Life Satisfaction and Health in Old Age. International Journal of Science and Research 4: 1276-1281.
- Gokdemir O, Tahsin E (2014) Factors that Influence the Life Satisfaction of Women Living in the Northern Cyprus. Social Indicators Research 115: 1071-1085.
- ?o?nierczuk-Kieliszek D, Kulik TB, Janiszewska M, Stefanowicz A (2014) Influence of sociodemographic factors on quality of life in women living in Lublin Province in Poland. Prz Menopauzalny 13: 13-17.
- Shallal M (2011) Job Satisfaction among Women in the United Arab Emirates. Journal of International Women's Studies 12: 114-34.
- Alam QG, Srivastava R (1971) Manual for Life Satisfaction Scale. National Psychological Corporation, Agra.
- Parashar M, Singh M, Kishore J, Pathak R, Panda M (2017) Prevalence and Correlates of stress among working women of a tertiary health centre in Delhi, India. Indian Journal of Medical Specialities 8: 77-81.
- Abu Hallalah ASM, Jorissen SL, Niaz K, Qarni AMAA (2014) Job Stress and Job Satisfaction Among Health Care Professionals. European Scientific Journal 10: 156-173.
- Jan M , Masood T (2008) An Assessment of Life Satisfaction among Women. Stud Home Comm. Sci 21: 33-42.
- Jadhav SG (2013) A Study of Life Satisfaction of Working Women and Housewives. Indian Streams Research Journal 2: 1-4.
- Hegney DG, Craigie M, Hemsworth D, Osseiran-Moisson R, Aoun S, et al. (2014) Compassion satisfaction, compassion fatigue, anxiety, depression and stress in registered nurses in Australia: study 1 results. J Nurs Manage 22: 506-518.
- Chiang YM, Chang, Y (2012) Stress, depression, and intention to leave among nurses in different medical units: implications for healthcare management/ nursing practice. Health Policy 108: 149-157.
- Edwards D, Burnard P (2003) A systematic review of stress and stress management interventions for mental health nurses. J Adv Nurs 42: 169-200.
- Park K (2011) Parks textbook of preventive and social medicine, (23rd edn), Jabalpur: M/s Banarsidas Bhanot Medicine and Social Sciences, India. Pg no: 670.
- Starmer AJ, Frintner MP, Freed GL (2016) Work–Life Balance, Burnout, and Satisfaction of Early Career Pediatricians. Pediatrics 137.
Citation: Parashar M, Singh M, Lal P, Pathak R (2017) Life Satisfaction and Correlates among Working Women of a Tertiary Care Health Sector: A Cross Sectional Study from Delhi. J Psychiatry Depress Anxiety 3: 009.
Copyright: © 2017 Mamta Parashar, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.